Page 1 of 1

Category puzzle

Posted: 05 Mar 2008 16:57
by JohnK
I've just put on a complete musical on the life of John the Baptist (by John Earwaker). This gave some interesting category questions.
1. The theme could be called "sacred" - but it lies in none of the sacred categories.
2. But there isn't a secular category for a "musical" either. (I've gone for operas - not quite right, somehow.)
3. How many "voices" are there when there are 12 soloists, a chorus sometimes in unison and sometimes in SATB, children (probably), and in one place a 5-part round with a hymn above? 4v and SATB doesn't feel right.
4. It's a single work but has to be presented as full score, vocal score, script, parts, etc.. Difficult to say "how many pages" or "how many KB".
Never mind! it's up.

Posted: 05 Mar 2008 20:11
by DaveF
John,

It's true we're rather short on categories on CPDL - the choices, for example, for shorter sacred works seems basically to be between "Motet" and "Anthem", which is a bit vague in musicological terms. Cousin John, however, sounds rather sui generis from your description - although would Oratorio be a better fit?

DF

Posted: 05 Mar 2008 20:38
by bobnotts
Dave - I'm intrigued - what other genres of short sacred works are you thinking of?

Posted: 05 Mar 2008 20:50
by CHGiffen
ummmm... Antiphons, Carols, Anglican chants, Evening canticles, Morning canticles, Hymns, Sacred sons, Spirituals (to name a few)... :)

Chuck

Posted: 06 Mar 2008 20:19
by DaveF
What I should have said was that there are plenty of other categories, but these are hardly used - the Sacred Songs category, for example, has one member - and the amount of work involved in assigning everything to the appropriate category would be enormous.

DF