Errors in the William Smith Responses
Posted: 28 Jul 2009 21:44
I figure that you would like to know about errors in scores, but I don't know exactly where to send the list. So I decided to post it here, with the hope that one of the administrators will pass it on.
These are the errors I found in the edition by John Henry Fowler. I must say that I like this edition and that it is much easier to read than the two-stave version published by Oxford.
Bracketing: There should only be one bracket, connecting the two alto parts; there should be no bracket for tenor and bass.
Measure 6, bass: The notes for 'haste to help' should all be in measure 7 (measure 6, as it stands, has 5 beats).
Measure 18, tenor and bass: the syllable 'out' should be moved one note to the left, so that it is under the quarter note.
M20, S: There is a quarter note a-flat missing; it should follow the dotted half note, and the syllable 'the' should be under the a-flat.
M32, B: The first note of the Amen should be a D-flat, not an E-flat.
M48, all parts: the word 'thy' should be 'thine'.
M51, reciting note: should be an A-flat, not a B-flat.
M54, all parts: the word 'fightest' should be 'fighteth'.
M60, S: There is an extra note, the quarter-note B-flat should be omitted
M60, Alto I: the syllable 'ly' should be moved one note left so that it is under the B-flat.
M68, S: the syllables 'men' and 'A' should move one note to the right, so that 'men' is under the A-flat.
Many thanks for all you do here; this is a wonderful resource.
Christopher Uhl
July 28, 2009
These are the errors I found in the edition by John Henry Fowler. I must say that I like this edition and that it is much easier to read than the two-stave version published by Oxford.
Bracketing: There should only be one bracket, connecting the two alto parts; there should be no bracket for tenor and bass.
Measure 6, bass: The notes for 'haste to help' should all be in measure 7 (measure 6, as it stands, has 5 beats).
Measure 18, tenor and bass: the syllable 'out' should be moved one note to the left, so that it is under the quarter note.
M20, S: There is a quarter note a-flat missing; it should follow the dotted half note, and the syllable 'the' should be under the a-flat.
M32, B: The first note of the Amen should be a D-flat, not an E-flat.
M48, all parts: the word 'thy' should be 'thine'.
M51, reciting note: should be an A-flat, not a B-flat.
M54, all parts: the word 'fightest' should be 'fighteth'.
M60, S: There is an extra note, the quarter-note B-flat should be omitted
M60, Alto I: the syllable 'ly' should be moved one note left so that it is under the B-flat.
M68, S: the syllables 'men' and 'A' should move one note to the right, so that 'men' is under the A-flat.
Many thanks for all you do here; this is a wonderful resource.
Christopher Uhl
July 28, 2009