Musica Ficta in Mateo Flecha's Teresica Hermana

Discussions relating to performance, interpretation, score preparation, musica ficta etc.
Locked
dildpc
Posts: 1
Joined: 04 Aug 2011 12:21

Musica Ficta in Mateo Flecha's Teresica Hermana

Post by dildpc »

Hi, well, my knowledge of Ficta rules leads me towards some choices contradicted by the vihuelists's versions (De Fuenllana and De Valderrábano). Things get even more complicated since De Fuenllana and De Valderrábano don't agree themselves...Attached is a score with the added fictas used in De Fuenllana version.
Thank you!
Attachments
Teresica hermana Fictas according to the De Fuenllana version for voice and vihuela pages 3 to 5.pdf
(1.64 MiB) Downloaded 40 times
Teresica hermana Fictas according to the De Fuenllana version for voice and vihuela pages 1 and 2.pdf
(1.24 MiB) Downloaded 31 times
Cdalitz
Posts: 172
Joined: 24 Apr 2007 14:42

Re: Musica Ficta in Mateo Flecha's Teresica Hermana

Post by Cdalitz »

What is your question?

I guess you refer to the consecution of F sharp and B flat in bar 86, which seems to be against the ficta rules. But as the tablature by Fuenllana is un refutable evidence that this progression was used indeed, whay would you want to change it?

Note that this same cadence also violates a rule of renaissance counterpoint by not preparing the dissonance in the tenor in bar 85 with a syncope. I would thus not be too monastic with respect to the apllication of ficta rules.
Locked